The "Problematic" God of the Old Testament

First Q & A episode! Focusing on the theme of our problems with the God of the Old Testament. What do we make of the Old Testament's theme of religious violence (e.g. the wiping out of the Canaanites)?  How should we think about salvation for people outside of Abraham's family before Christ? Why does God seem so intent on judging and punishing all the time? What is the purpose of God's choosing one specific people to the exclusion of everyone else? 

A couple of years ago, famous Christian author and pastor, Andy Stanley, declared that it was time time to “unhitch” Christianity from the Old Testament. Whatever he meant by that, it created quite a stir. People were offended. (Ok, I was offended.) But if you actually go and read a few chapters of the Old Testament--just turn to almost any page--you can kind of see what he means. Many of us became Christians because of our captivation with the person of Jesus. But compared to the Jesus of the Gospels , the religion of the Old Testament--and yes, even the God of the Old Testament--can seem unrecognizable.

Our discomfort with the Old Testament has given rise to two major problems, which tend to converge and form a kind of vicious cycle: the first is a lack of knowledge. The second, a lack of trust. Personally, I'm more concerned about the second. Does it matter that the average Young Life leader has read very little of the Old Testament and/or knows almost nothing about it? Yes it matters. But you don’t have to be a Hebrew scholar or an expert on the Old Testament in order to believe in the gospel of Jesus Christ and share it with others. But if, already believing in Jesus, you open up the Old Testament and find a problematic religion you do not recognize and a problematic God you cannot trust...that is a bigger problem. 

Inasmuch as we cannot recognize Yahweh in the person of Jesus (and vice versa), the vicious cycle of ignorance and mistrust will continue to erode our faith, so that, in the end, not even Jesus’s words and deeds will fully resonate. We’ll be tempted to pick and choose the parts of Jesus we like, just as we’ve already done with the rest of the Bible. Maybe we'll pick the parts that conveniently fit with our own personal narrative and unhitch ourselves from the rest. Of course, in some ways, we’re already doing this. So we have to backtrack, to dive deeper into the well (as I always say), which requires some patience--and a bit of bewilderment. But in the end, I guarantee it’s worth it. 

Hope you enjoy! Special thanks to Mariel Kondas for the great question. Please keep the questions coming: rossebyrd@gmail.com. Also, check out our new website: www.meresanity.com.